​2020
AJ Mirgon
​2nd Team Quarterback

---

​2019
Jacob Curl
​3rd Team Lineman

---

​2018
Cannon Blauser
​1st Team Linebacker

​2018
Jack Duffer
​1st Team Wide Receiver

​2018
Griffin Veil
​1st Team Quarterback

​2018
Daniel Vazquez
​2nd Team Lineman

​2018
Patrick Day
3rd Team Defensive Back

---

​2017
Daevon Anderson
​1st Team Wide Receiver

2017
Cannon Blauser
​2nd Team Linebacker

2017
Josh Stewart
​2nd Team Quarterback

---

2016
Will Phillis
​Division 1- Ohio Offensive Player of the Year

---

2016
Will Phillis
​1st Team Quarterback

2016
Daevon Anderson
​1st Team Wide Receiver

---

2015
Brady Whittekind
​2nd Team Kicker

---

2013
​Skylar Hartley
2nd Team Lineman​

2015
Chris Wall
Special Mention Linebacker

---

2011
Tony Harvard
Honorable Mention Lineman​