1st Team

Mitchell Robinson Jr, Linebacker- 2021
​Cannon Blauser, Linebacker- 2018
​Jack Duffer, Wide Receiver- 2018
Daevon Anderson, Wide Receiver- 2017
​Daevon Anderson, Wide Receiver- 2016

---

2nd Team

Cannon Blauser, Linebacker- 2017
Chris Wall, Linebacker- 2015
​Skylar Hartley, Offensive Lineman- 2013
​Tony Harvard, Defensive Lineman- 2011

---

Special Mention

Caden VanVorhis, Defensive Back- 2021
​AJ Mirgon, Quarterback- 2020
Jack Pugh, Tight End- 2020
​Caden VanVorhis, Linebacker- 2020
Josh Stewart, Quarterback- 2017
Kory Taylor, Wide Receiver- 2017
Obi Igwe, Offensive Line- 2017
Danny Vazquez, Offensive Line- 2017
​Adam McCardle, Linebacker- 2017