2024
Terris Dudley
3rd Team Defensive Back
2023
Bradyn Fleharty
1st Team Quarterback
2023
Ethen Tebbetts
1st Team Linebacker
2023
Julian Dandridge
Honorable Mention

2022

EJ Teah

3rd Team Linebacker
2021
Caden VanVorhis
3rd Team Defensive Back
2021
Mitchell Robinson Jr
​Honorable Mention Linebacker
​

​2020
AJ Mirgon
​2nd Team Quarterback

​2019
Jacob Curl
​3rd Team Lineman

​2018
Cannon Blauser
​1st Team Linebacker

​2018
Jack Duffer
​1st Team Wide Receiver

​2018
Griffin Veil
​1st Team Quarterback

​2018
Daniel Vazquez
​2nd Team Lineman

​2018
Patrick Day
3rd Team Defensive Back

​2017
Daevon Anderson
​1st Team Wide Receiver

2017
Cannon Blauser
​2nd Team Linebacker

2017
Josh Stewart
​2nd Team Quarterback

2016
Will Phillis
​Division 1- Ohio Offensive Player of the Year

2016
Will Phillis
​1st Team Quarterback

2016
Daevon Anderson
​1st Team Wide Receiver

2015
Brady Whittekind
​2nd Team Kicker

2013
​Skylar Hartley
2nd Team Lineman​

2015
Chris Wall
Special Mention Linebacker

2011
Tony Harvard
Honorable Mention Lineman​